The best sandwich shops in Eagle, Idaho

There are so many options when it comes to sandwiches, but whichever kind you like, it is important to find a sandwich shop that knows what they are doing.

If you live in Eagle, Idaho, we’ve got you covered with a list of the best sandwich shops in the area.


Eagle residents can find Tasso at 342 East State Street. It’s a cute little sandwich shop with a great patio where you can eat lunch in the sunshine. Since the ingredients are of such high quality, the meal that is produced as a direct result is superior. Many restaurants put a lot of sauce on their sandwiches to make them taste good, but Tasso’s sandwiches rely on solid ingredients and a decent balance. You will love all the organic alternatives they provide; every sweetener they sell is vegan.


Eagle residents can find Rembrandts at 93 South Eagle Road. American and café fare are two of their available options. Vegetarian-friendly options, Vegan options, and gluten-free options are available for those following particular diets. The locals know this is an excellent location for conducting short business meetings, having breakfast or lunch, or both. This former church has been given a modern makeover that not only makes it more spacious but also makes it cozier. The furnishings are understated and classy. Their offerings include drinks in addition to breakfast, lunch, dinner and brunch.

The Stuffed Olive

The Stuffed Olive, found in Eagle at 404 South Eagle Road, is known for having the most delicious Italian dinner in the area. It is a charming establishment that is just the thing for a small gathering of people or a couple looking for a romantic ambiance. There is a rapid turnover of customers on Friday and Saturday nights. One of the best items is the handmade macaroni and bacon. The shrimp scampi is excellent with angel hair pasta, and the steak is perfectly cooked. A great dessert option is homemade panna cotta topped with berries or chocolate. Also, give the warm mulled wine a shot—it’s the greatest you’ll ever have!

Earl of Sandwich

It can be reached at the following address: 3775 N. Eagle Road. Not where one would typically anticipate finding a sandwich or Sub business. The bakery emits an aroma that is tantalizingly reminiscent of freshly baked bread. There are just hot subs on the menu, and they provide a variety of standard sandwiches in addition to others that are more unique. The sandwiches are split in half, which allows for easier handling and makes them ideal for sharing. The location is a little unique as it’s inside a convenience store, but it is spotless, and there is a grilling space. The service is satisfactory.

Fat Guy’s Fresh Deli

These sandwiches are incredible, with a fantastic marinade. The soup is tasty, and the cookies are wonderfully chewy and soft. The price of the meal includes not just the entrée, but also a side dish (potato salad, coleslaw, or chips), as well as a drink. Because there is a wide variety of sandwich options, making a decision might be challenging. Additionally, each day features a unique and fresh soup selection.

There are so many great places to eat in Eagle, which is yet another reason why so many people like to call it home. If you are interested in Eagle real estate, contact us today!